Articles / Blog / Featured / Innovation

The Evolution of the U.S. Payment Systems

by Bob Bartleson · Published February 22, 2024 · Updated November 10, 2024

Executive Summary

U.S. payment systems, once dominated by established card networks, stand at a crossroads. The rise of fintech innovation and the burgeoning popularity of digital wallets are simultaneously disruptive and fragmented, presenting both roadblocks and immense opportunities. While traditional models offer widespread acceptance, their limitations in innovation, higher fees, and poor data insights are becoming increasingly apparent.

This white paper delves into the forces shaping this dynamic landscape. The data reveals a growing influence of digital wallets, highlighting their potential to revolutionize the way we pay, shop, and interact with financial services. An examination of the challenges and opportunities associated with fragmentation and privacy concerns, reveals the crucial need for financial inclusion. Further exploration shows the potential of closed-loop systems like Alipay and WeChat Pay, and their ability to disrupt with lower fees and seamless integration.

Furthermore, this analysis considers the feasibility of a unified closed-loop network for the U.S., evaluating its potential to streamline transactions, enhance data exchange, and drive adoption. Highlighting disruptive mobile payment solutions like M-Pesa in emerging markets, this paper showcases their power to overcome access barriers and empower unbanked populations.

Looking specifically at the U.S. retail ecosystem, this paper proposes the concept of hybrid networks, drawing strength from both open and closed systems. This innovative approach offers merchants lower fees, seamless loyalty program integration, and deeper customer engagement. To guide new entrants navigating this ever-shifting terrain, five key strategies for success are outlined, emphasizing a focus on specific value propositions, strong ecosystem partnerships, and data-driven security practices.

By understanding the forces at play, established players, new entrants, and investors can seize the opportunities presented by this seismic shift and positively shape the future of payments in the United States.

The History of U.S. Payment Systems

The modern payment system in the U.S. emerged with the widespread adoption of credit cards in the post-WWII era. These closed-loop systems, like VISA and MasterCard, facilitated secure transactions through a three-party network: cardholders, merchants, and issuing banks. The key driver of their early success was the convenience they offered compared to cash, alongside lucrative interchange fees – a percentage of each transaction paid by the merchant to the issuing bank. This fee structure, while profitable for card networks and issuers, became a point of contention for merchants, leading to lawsuits and regulatory scrutiny (Casetext, 2013).

However, the rise of card dominance was soon challenged by the emergence of debit cards and debit networks like PULSE and NYCE. Offering lower interchange fees than their credit card counterparts, debit cards gained traction among cost-conscious consumers and merchants alike. This competition, coupled with the Durbin-Amon amendment of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act in 2010, led to a reduction in interchange fees for debit transactions, further impacting the profitability of card networks (University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School, 2019).

Disrupting the Status Quo

The 21st century ushered in a wave of fintech innovation, shaking the foundations of the established payment system. Startup payment gateways, like Stripe and Square, armed with cutting-edge technologies and agile business models challenged the dominance of traditional players, offering faster, cheaper, and more convenient alternatives.

One key area of disruption was peer-to-peer (P2P) payments. Platforms like Venmo and Zelle leveraged mobile technology to enable seamless person-to-person money transfers, bypassing the traditional card networks and their associated fees (McKinsey & Company, 2019). This shift reflected a growing consumer preference for instant and cost-effective transactions, particularly among younger demographics.

Beyond P2P, fintechs also targeted the burgeoning mobile payments space. Apple Pay, Google Pay, and Samsung Pay emerged as major players, leveraging near-field communication (NFC) technology to facilitate contactless payments through mobile devices. These platforms offered a seamless and secure experience, further eroding the reliance on physical cards (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, 2023).

The Future of Payments

The rise of mobile payments has been closely intertwined with the evolution of digital wallets. Digital wallets offer several advantages over traditional methods:

Convenience: They eliminate the need to carry cash or physical cards, simplifying the payment process, and can include features like bill pay, person-to-person transfers, and even in-store payments through QR codes.
Security: Many wallets incorporate tokenization and encryption technologies, enhancing security and reducing the risk of fraud.
Rewards and loyalty programs: Many wallets offer integrated rewards programs and loyalty points, incentivizing their use.
Data and insights: Wallets collect valuable data on user spending habits, which can be used for targeted marketing and personalized financial services.

This multi-faceted approach has fueled the adoption of digital wallets, making them a central element of the digital payment ecosystem. Merchants are increasingly accepting them, recognizing their convenience and potential to attract tech-savvy consumers. Additionally, digital wallets are paving the way for new financial services, such as buy-now-pay-later (BNPL) offerings and embedded finance solutions, further blurring the lines between traditional payments and other financial activities.

Challenges and Opportunities

Despite the undeniable progress, U.S. payment systems face several challenges:

Fragmentation: The multitude of payment methods and platforms creates confusion and complexity for both consumers and merchants.
Privacy concerns: The collection and use of user data by payment providers raises concerns about privacy and data security.
Financial inclusion: Ensuring equitable access to digital payment solutions for all segments of the population remains a critical challenge.

However, these challenges also present significant opportunities for innovation and growth. Continued advancements in technology such as AI, coupled with regulatory frameworks that promote competition and address privacy concerns, can pave the way for a more efficient, inclusive, and user-centric payments ecosystem.

The legacy of traditional networks, the disruptive force of fintech, and the ongoing innovation of digital wallets paint a dynamic picture of a rapidly changing industry. For those navigating this transformation, embracing innovation while addressing existing challenges will be critical in shaping a future of secure, convenient, and accessible payments for all.

The Burgeoning Digital Wallet Ecosystem

The digital wallet revolution is reshaping the US payments environment, offering consumers unparalleled convenience and security while presenting both opportunities and challenges for retailers and financial institutions.

The adoption of digital wallets in the US is on an upward trajectory. According to Statista, transactions performed on mobile wallets in North America during 2020 came to $502.76 billion and are projected to almost double to $930 billion in 2024 (Statista, 2024). This growth is fueled by several factors:

Smartphone penetration: With 90% of Americans owning smartphones (Pew Research Center, 2024), the infrastructure for mobile wallets is readily available.
Increased convenience: Digital wallets offer a faster and more convenient checkout experience compared to traditional cards, eliminating the need to fumble for plastic.
Enhanced security: Tokenization and biometric authentication features in digital wallets offer improved security compared to physical cards, reducing fraud risk.
Integration with loyalty programs: Some wallets integrate with loyalty programs, offering users seamless rewards accumulation and redemption.

However, the popularity of different digital wallets varies. Google Pay, Apple Pay, and Samsung Pay are leading players, with Apply Pay commanding 48% of in-person digital wallet transactions (Business.com, 2024). Other notable players include PayPal, Venmo, and Zelle, each catering to specific user segments and preferences.

Efficacy and Shortcomings for Physical Retailers

For physical retailers, digital wallets offer both advantages and challenges.

Advantages:

Faster checkout: Contactless payments through digital wallets lead to faster checkout times, reducing queues and improving the customer experience.
Reduced fraud: Tokenization and encryption features in digital wallets decrease the risk of fraud for both retailers and customers.
Data insights: Some digital wallets provide valuable data on consumer spending habits, which can be used for targeted marketing and inventory management.

Shortcomings:

Acceptance and fragmentation hurdles: Not all retailers accept all digital wallets, creating confusion and inconvenience for customers. Additionally, the fragmented ecosystem with multiple competing platforms can create integration complexities, requiring retailers to support various solutions.
Fees and privacy concerns: Merchant fees associated with some digital wallets can be higher compared to traditional cards, impacting profitability. Furthermore, concerns around data privacy and ownership remain, adding another layer of complexity.
Program integration challenges: Integrating digital wallets with existing loyalty programs and point-of-sale systems can be complex and costly.

Fintechs Squeezing Bank Margins

The rise of fintechs, particularly those powering digital wallets, has undoubtedly impacted traditional merchant services. By offering innovative solutions that disrupt the traditional banking value chain, they are putting pressure on banks to reduce fees and innovate their offerings to remain competitive (McKinsey Global Banking Practices, 2021).

The rise of digital wallets has impacted bank margins for merchant services in several ways:

Reduced interchange fees: Unlike traditional credit cards, some digital wallets, like Venmo and Zelle, operate on minimal or no interchange fees, impacting banks’ revenue streams.
Increased competition: Fintech companies offering digital wallets often have lower operating costs compared to traditional banks, putting pressure on bank fees.
Shifting consumer preferences: Consumers increasingly opting for digital wallets with lower fees further erodes banks’ traditional revenue streams.
Analytics and Marketing: Fintech companies behind these wallets often provide value-added services like data analytics and marketing tools, further enticing merchants to switch.

However, the relationship between fintechs and banks is not solely competitive. Partnerships are emerging, where banks leverage fintech expertise to offer enhanced merchant services and compete more effectively. This collaborative approach can create a win-win situation for all parties involved.

A Multi-Billion-Dollar Opportunity

The digital wallet market is a rapidly growing space, attracting significant investment and generating substantial revenue. Google Pay and Apple Pay, backed by their vast ecosystems and user bases, are leading the charge. Samsung Pay enjoys a strong presence in the Android market. Other contenders like PayPal and Venmo offer broader financial services beyond just payments, diversifying their revenue streams.

According to Juniper Research, the global mobile wallet transaction value is expected to increase from $9 trillion in 2023 to surpass $16 trillion in 2028, a rise of 77% (Juniper Research, 2023). Determining the payment services market valuation of multi-product leading players such as Apple Pay, Google Pay, and Samsung Pay is difficult. However, looking at some of the leading pure-play companies reflects the significant financial power within the digital wallet space.

Stripe Valuation $95 billion (2023)
PayPal Market Cap 67.3 billion
Square Market Cap 41.7 billion

Wallet Friction in a Seamless Future

Despite their promise, digital wallets currently lack seamless integration with loyalty programs, digital coupons, and in-store discounts. This fragmentation creates friction for consumers who often juggle multiple apps and cards during checkout. There are current efforts to address this challenge through collaboration between retailers, financial institutions, and technology providers to standardize protocols and enable smooth data exchange. Some of the more popular initiatives are:

Industry standards: Organizations like the EMVCo are developing standards for interoperable digital wallets, which could facilitate broader acceptance and integration.
Open-loop platforms: Platforms like Fiserv and MasterCard Send are enabling merchants to accept various digital wallets through a single integration.
Partnerships: Some retailers are partnering with specific digital wallet providers to offer integrated loyalty programs and promotions.

However, the fragmented landscape of digital wallets necessitates exploring solutions beyond ongoing collaborative efforts. The concept of a unified closed-loop network, encompassing all merchants, could potentially bridge the integration gap by enabling seamless transactions across existing networks, P2P transfers, and integrated loyalty programs and digital coupons. Some potential benefits (as well as challenges) of a unified closed-loop network include:

Seamless Transactions: By creating a common platform for different payment methods, networks, and loyalty programs, users could enjoy a unified and frictionless experience across various merchants. This could include everything from P2P transfers to in-store payments with coupons and rewards seamlessly applied.
Reduced Fragmentation: By consolidating various players into one network, the complexity currently faced by both merchants and consumers could be significantly reduced. This could save costs for merchants and improve usability for consumers.
Enhanced Incentives: Integrating loyalty programs and digital coupons into the network could create a powerful rewards ecosystem, incentivizing both consumers and merchants to participate.
Data Advantage: The network could potentially gather rich data on user behavior and preferences, enabling targeted marketing and personalized offers, potentially benefiting both users and merchants.

Challenges and Considerations:

Competition and Regulatory Hurdles: Gaining buy-in from all major players within the payment systems, including established networks, fintechs, and large retailers, could be difficult due to competition and potential regulatory scrutiny.
Privacy Concerns: Integrating various data sources raises concerns about user privacy and data security, requiring robust safeguards and transparent data handling practices.
Network Neutrality: Ensuring equal access and fair terms for all participants would be critical to avoid accusations of stifling competition or favoring certain players within the network.
Technical Complexity: Building and maintaining such a complex network with interoperability across various systems would require significant technical expertise and resources.

Examining the feasibility of such a network requires careful consideration of technical complexities, regulatory requirements, and potential competition within the payment ecosystem. Despite these challenges, a closed-loop network could offer significant advantages, including streamlining in-store transactions, enhancing data exchange, and potentially increasing transaction volume. Seamless integration would further enhance the customer experience, drive greater adoption, and unlock the full potential of digital wallets in physical stores.

Disruption and Innovation Beyond the West

While digital wallets have been gaining traction in the West, their impact in emerging markets has been even more transformative. Platforms like Alipay, WeChat Pay, and M-Pesa have not only disrupted traditional payment systems but also revolutionized financial inclusion and access in economies with large unbanked populations.

Alipay (China): Pioneering Digital Payments with Widespread Adoption

Founded in 2004, Alipay partnered with Alibaba, the e-commerce giant, to facilitate secure online payments. It quickly gained traction, disrupting the cash-dominated Chinese market by offering a convenient and trustworthy alternative. Alipay addressed several key problems:

Low bank penetration: Enabled access to financial services for the unbanked and underbanked, estimated at over 159 million in China in 2021 (World Bank, 2022).
Limited trust in traditional systems: Provided a secure and transparent platform for online transactions, overcoming concerns about fraud.
Micropayments: Alipay facilitated small, everyday transactions previously impractical with traditional methods, boosting financial inclusion.
Lack of convenient payment options: Offered a seamless solution for online and in-store payments, replacing cumbersome cash transactions.

Despite initial regulatory hurdles, Alipay’s innovative approach and strategic partnerships propelled its growth. Today, it dominates the Chinese digital wallet market with over 54% share (EnterpiseAppsToday, 2023), and its holding company, Alibaba Group, enjoys a market capitalization exceeding $188 billion (Companiesmarketcap.com, 2024).

WeChat Pay (China): Social Power Meets Financial Inclusion

Launched in 2011 by Tencent, WeChat Pay leveraged its existing user base and social connections to disrupt mobile payments. It addressed similar challenges as Alipay but with a focus on peer-to-peer (P2P) payments and microtransactions within the WeChat ecosystem.

Enhanced convenience: Enabled seamless P2P transfers and in-store payments within the WeChat app, fostering a frictionless social and financial experience.
Financial inclusion: Catered to the unbanked and underbanked through its user-friendly interface and integration with existing social networks.

WeChat Pay’s rapid growth was fueled by its social network integration, strategic partnerships, and focus on micro-transactions. It rivals Alipay in market share with an impressive 42% (EnterpiseAppsToday, 2023), and its holding company, Tencent Holdings, has a market capitalization exceeding $343 billion (Companiesmarketcap.com, 2024).

M-Pesa (Kenya): Financial Inclusion Pioneer in Sub-Saharan Africa

Launched in 2007 by Vodafone, M-Pesa revolutionized the Kenyan mobile payment systems. It addressed a critical challenge in a region with limited banking infrastructure:

Financial exclusion: Provided access to financial services for the unbanked and underbanked, estimated at over 80% in Kenya in 2006 (Shared Value Initiative, 2011)
Limited cash access: Offered a secure and convenient way to transfer money, pay bills, and access savings, reducing dependence on cash.

M-Pesa’s success relied on its partnerships with mobile network operators, agent networks, and a focus on user education. Today, it boasts over 50 million users, dominates the Kenyan mobile money market and is in seven African countries (McKinsey & Company, 2022).

Challenges and the Road Ahead

While these mobile payment powerhouses have achieved remarkable success, they face several challenges:

Regulation: Balancing innovation with regulatory compliance remains a complex issue, particularly regarding data privacy and anti-money laundering regulations.
Competition: The global mobile payment market is increasingly competitive, with new players emerging and established players vying for market share.
Security: Ensuring robust security measures against fraud and data breaches is crucial for maintaining user trust and confidence.
Sustainability: Balancing profitability with financial inclusion for unbanked and underbanked populations remains a challenge for some players.

Despite these challenges, the future of mobile payments is loaded with potential. The rise of global mobile payment systems like Alipay, WeChat Pay, and M-Pesa has marked a significant shift in how people manage their finances. By addressing the needs of the unbanked and underbanked, fostering financial inclusion, and offering unparalleled convenience, these players have disrupted traditional financial systems and demonstrated the immense potential of mobile payments.

As existing players navigate the evolving landscape, they pave the way for new entrants to capitalize on exciting opportunities. Looking ahead, both established players and new entrants can further revolutionize financial services, drive inclusion, and empower individuals globally. By fostering innovation, collaboration, and responsible regulations, mobile payment systems can reach their full potential and pave the way for a more financially inclusive and empowering future.

Reimagining Payment Systems in the US

Unlike their counterparts in regions dominated by closed-loop systems like Alipay and WeChat Pay, physical retailers in the US face a complex digital payments ecosystem, riddled with challenges for both them and their customers. While traditional payment networks offer wide acceptance, they still inadequately address the underbanked and unbanked consumers. Additionally, they have yet to overcome key merchant pain points of high fees, slow innovation, and limited data insights.

For banks, navigating evolving payment systems hinges on a crucial decision: build and manage their networks, demanding significant investment, or cede control to third parties, risking dependence. Smaller banks seek regional alliances to overcome scale limitations, while larger institutions collaborate on schemes like Zelle, recognizing the power of market share in setting standards. Finding the right balance between independent control and strategic partnerships will be critical for incumbents to thrive in this dynamic environment.

Expanding reach and efficiency can be achieved through improving existing infrastructure and connecting national debit schemes across regions, potentially through collaboration with acquirers or global schemes. However, pricing will be key as excessive profit margins by banks risk drawing regulatory scrutiny and attracting undercutting competition. Striking the sweet spot between profitability and market competitiveness necessitates careful consideration by established players.

Beyond the immediate burdens of high fees, limited data insights, and sluggish innovation, US payment systems present deeper strategic challenges for players across the value chain.

Contrasting with Other Markets

While open networks in the US boast wider acceptance for various payment methods, the limitations in innovation, fees, and data access compared to closed-loop models are stark. The success stories of Alipay and WeChat Pay in China demonstrate the potential of such payment systems. These closed-loop networks, operating within self-contained ecosystems, offer:

Lower Fees: By controlling both issuing and acquiring functions, they can bypass traditional network fees, leading to lower transaction costs for merchants.
Targeted Rewards: Integration with loyalty programs and other services allows for personalized rewards and deeper customer engagement.
Financial Inclusion: Serving the unbanked and underbanked population who may lack traditional bank accounts is a core feature of these networks.

Recognizing the limitations of traditional open networks, global payment players are exploring alternative strategies to replicate the strengths of closed-loop models like Alipay and WeChat Pay. Collaborative efforts like VISA’s partnership with Tencent for WeChat Pay access and PayPal’s deal with Google Pay exemplify successful co-acceptance agreements that expand reach and acceptance without full acquisitions. Additionally, targeted acquisitions focusing on specific functionalities are gaining traction. For instance, a payments provider might acquire an API developer to enhance data processing capabilities, mimicking the seamless data integration offered by closed-loop systems. These strategic moves highlight a shift beyond traditional network dominance, suggesting a future where collaboration and targeted advancements bridge the gap between open and closed-loop models, ultimately benefiting both merchants and consumers.

Market Opportunity for Disruption

The US market presents a significant opportunity for disruption through hybrid networks that combine the benefits of traditional acceptance with the innovation and flexibility of closed-loop models. This can be achieved through:

Fostering Collaborative Ecosystems: Partnerships between retailers, technology companies, and financial institutions can create self-contained ecosystems powered by hybrid networks. These networks offer lower fees, seamless integration with loyalty programs and rewards, and deeper customer engagement, incentivizing adoption, and driving growth.
Leveraging Existing Open-Loop Networks: Retailers can capitalize on established open-loop networks like MasterCard Send or VISA Direct to offer unique features while maintaining wide acceptance. This approach allows for innovation within the existing infrastructure, offering flexibility and potentially faster implementation.
Building a Consortium-Based Network: Retailers can join forces to create a collective issuing and acquiring network, leveraging their combined bargaining power to negotiate lower fees with existing networks. This collaborative approach offers economies of scale and potentially greater control over the network’s development.

Regardless of the chosen approach, successfully building and scaling a hybrid network requires a strategic roadmap. Drawing insights from established players like GrubHub, Flywire, and Amazon, the following is a four-step guide (McKinsey Global Banking Practices, 2021):

Identify Your Seed Population and Ecosystem

Pinpoint a critical mass of senders and receivers within your ecosystem who regularly make payments, such as your customer base, suppliers, or external entities with unmet needs.
Consider partnering with established players in specific niches to accelerate growth and leverage their experience.

Enable Frictionless Internal Payments

Implement direct-to-account methods like Plaid or open-banking APIs to offer cost-effective and convenient internal transactions, fostering engagement and laying the foundation for expansion.

Define Rules, Standards, and Branding

Establish clear rules and standards for participation, similar to the evolution of Swish in Sweden.
Make key branding decisions: will your network operate under a separate identity, and how will merchants communicate acceptance?
Determine data access protocols, pricing structures, and fraud liability rules to ensure smooth operation and user trust.

Expand Reach and Facilitate Adoption

Create diverse access points for new participants, including onboarding channels, API integration for third-party distribution, and dedicated marketing and sales efforts.
Partner with regional acquirers to further increase acceptance and leverage their established networks.

By following these steps and adapting them to their specific context, organizations can build robust hybrid networks that thrive in the dynamic U.S. payments arena. By prioritizing user experience, embracing innovation, and navigating the regulations strategically, these networks can unlock significant value for all stakeholders involved, ultimately reshaping the future of payment systems in the United States.

Value Proposition

Hybrid payment networks present a compelling value proposition for various stakeholders, by combining the widespread acceptance of traditional models with the agility and flexibility of closed-loop systems.

Seamlessly blending the reach of traditional networks with the flexibility of closed-loop models, these innovations offer a multifaceted value proposition that benefits merchants, consumers, and the overall financial system. Their impact extends beyond simply processing transactions. Hybrid networks offer:

Reduced Costs: Lower transaction fees for merchants translate to lower prices and increased profitability.
Enhanced Customer Experience: Personalized rewards, seamless payments, and data-driven insights can improve customer satisfaction and loyalty.
Financial Inclusion: Serving the unbanked and underbanked population expands the customer base and fosters economic growth.
Data-Driven Insights: Deeper integration across the ecosystem creates valuable data for personalized marketing and improved customer service.

The potential payoff for innovating in the payments industry is undeniable. Established payments players have garnered impressive returns in recent years, significantly outperforming broader financial sectors like banks and credit card issuers. In fact, over a five-year period from 2015 to 2020, most payment providers (excluding credit card issuers) even surpassed the benchmark S&P 500. This trend underscores the inherent value proposition of disrupting existing payment systems.

Further breakdown of the returns indicates a noteworthy 30% return for merchant and small business solutions providers, followed by payments networks at 24%. Even diversified fintechs enjoyed a robust 14% return, highlighting the overall growth potential within the industry. Notably, these figures stand in stark contrast to the anemic 4% and negative 4% returns experienced by traditional banks and credit card issuers, respectively.

These compelling figures present a powerful argument for embracing innovation and disruption within the payments ecosystem. By capitalizing on emerging technologies and evolving consumer preferences, new entrants and established players alike have the potential to unlock significant value and replicate the success stories showcased by McKinsey and Company’s chart. This creates a lucrative opportunity for investors seeking high-performing sectors and for industry players ready to redefine the future of payments.

Suggestions for Disruptors

As previous analysis demonstrated, the evolution in payments presents a lucrative opportunity for new entrants, presenting a compelling case for them to capture significant market share and substantial returns. Amidst digitally accelerated transformations, new entrants have a competitive advantage from their inherent agility, allowing them to tailor solutions to specific user needs across diverse segments, including regional communities, niche online ecosystems, and even hybrid systems. This adaptability contrasts with established players often burdened by legacy infrastructure. By offering user-friendly interfaces and relevant features designed specifically for these underserved demographics, new networks foster deep engagement and network effects.

Advantages to new entrants extend beyond user experience. Freed from the constraints of legacy systems, new entrants leverage their modern, purpose-built design to achieve significant cost savings. This translates to attractive pricing for participants, further fueling user acquisition and economies of scale. While established players may possess resources to replicate these efficiencies, their ability to adapt with the same agility remains an open question. In this dynamic situation, new entrants who capitalize on both superior user experiences and cost advantages are poised to not only disrupt the market but also capture significant value and redefine the future of payments.

Capitalizing on their inherent advantages is crucial, but the journey doesn’t stop there. To truly thrive, new entrants must also excel in five critical areas:

Focus on a specific value proposition: Clearly define the problem your solution addresses and the unique value it offers to both merchants and consumers.
Build a strong ecosystem: Partner with key players across the financial services, retail, and technology sectors to ensure wider acceptance and functionality.
Start small and scale strategically: Pilot your solution in specific segments or regions before scaling up nationally.
Prioritize data security and privacy: Building trust is crucial, so ensure robust data security measures and transparent data practices.
Embrace regulatory compliance: Navigate complex regulations surrounding data privacy and anti-money laundering to ensure long-term sustainability.

While established players pose a significant threat, their challenges present an opportunity. By focusing on these core advantages, new entrants can not only disrupt the landscape but also capture significant value in this dynamic and lucrative market.

Disrupting US payment systems requires a bold vision and a strategic approach. By leveraging hybrid networks, retailers and their partners can create solutions that address the key challenges of the current system and offer significant value to both merchants and consumers. As the market evolves, those who prioritize innovation, collaboration, and regulatory compliance will be best positioned to capture the immense potential for disruption and shape the future of retail payments in the US.

Sources:

Casetext. (2013). In re Payment Card Interchange Fee & Merch. Disc. Antitrust Litig. (Accessed Jan 29, 2024)

University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School. (2019). The Impact of the Durbin Amendment on Banks, Merchants, and Consumers. (Accessed Jan 29, 2024)

McKinsey & Company. (2019). Insights from McKinsey’s 2019 Digital Payments Survey. (Accessed Jan 29, 2024)

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. (2023) Big Tech’s Role in Contactless Payments: Analysis of Mobile Device Operating Systems and Tap-to-Pay Practices. (Accessed Jan 29, 2024)

Statista. (2024). Market size of mobile wallet transactions in various regions worldwide in 2020 with forecasts from 2021 to 2025. (Accessed Jan 29, 2024)

Pew Research Center. (2024) Mo bile Fact Sheet. (Accessed Jan 29, 2024)

Business.com. (2024). Mobile Wallet Guide: Google Pay vs. Apple Pay vs. Samsung Pay. (Accessed Jan 29, 2024)

McKinsey & Company. (2021). Global Banking Practices, McKinsey on Payments. (Accessed Jan 31, 2024)

Juniper Research. (2023) Fintech and Payments, Digital Wallets Transaction Value to Surpass $16 Trillion Globally by 2028. (Accessed Jan 31, 2024)

The World Bank. (2022). The Global Findex Database 2021. (Accessed Jan 31, 2024)

EnterpiseAppsToday. (2023) Statistics 2023 – Market Share, Facts and Marketing Trends. (Accessed Jan 31, 2024)